Close But No Cigar Origin

Vintage Cigar Box Labels

Have you ever heard the phrase "close but no cigar"? It's a popular expression used to describe a situation where someone almost succeeded but fell just short of their goal. The origin of this phrase is somewhat of a mystery, but there are a few theories about where it came from.

One Theory

Cigar

One theory is that the phrase originated at carnivals or fairs. Back in the day, one of the most popular prizes was a cigar. If you played a game and almost won, the carnival worker might say "close but no cigar" to let you know that you were close, but didn't quite make it. This theory is supported by the fact that cigars were a common prize at these types of events.

Another Theory

Cigar

Another theory is that the phrase has to do with the origins of cigars themselves. It's believed that the phrase may have come from the practice of testing the quality of a cigar by trying to blow smoke through the end of it. If the smoke came out the other end, it was considered a good cigar. If not, the cigar was no good. So, if someone almost succeeded in blowing smoke through the end of a cigar, they were "close but no cigar."

Yet Another Theory

Cigar

A third theory is that the phrase has to do with gambling. In poker, for example, if you have a good hand but don't win the pot, you might say "close but no cigar." The same could be true for other types of gambling, where you almost win but fall just short.

Conclusion

While we may never know the exact origin of the phrase "close but no cigar," it's interesting to speculate about where it came from. Regardless of its origins, the phrase has become a popular way to describe a situation where someone almost succeeded but fell just short. So, the next time you come close to achieving a goal, remember that you were "close but no cigar."

Related video of Close But No Cigar Origin